Sunday, October 13, 2013

A No-Win Fight




This post is written by Anshu Dhamiwal, an engineering student who writes poetry and blogs at Those Unsolved Conundrums. Whether it is poetry or prose, Anshu mostly writes about social issues plaguing women. Her in-depth articles speak with universal eloquence to anyone who has felt the pain of the underprivileged, and marginalized sections of our society. 


Prostitution: A no-win fight.



Sex is a taboo in India, therefore anything to do with sex is either looked down or ignored. Prostitution is one of them. It’s very much a part of our society but remains behind the curtains of morality.

Prostitution in simple words is the exchange of sexual services for money between two consenting adults. There have been contrasting views on whether to call it oldest profession or oldest form of exploitation of women by men.  Should it be seen as a consensual act, sexual liberation or slavery? Whatever the perception maybe, it cannot be denied that it is source of living to millions of people. Although our society has been insensitive to prostitutes but  it is our duty to choose a path which ensures their rights in society. There are possibly three ways to combat this problem:

• Legalize it and regulate it.

• Be diligent and completely uproot it.

• Existing laws should be executed perfectly.

Prostitution Now And Then

Prostitution is not something that popped out all of a sudden in 20th century; it has its roots somewhere 4000years ago. It has prevailed in ancient India. Sculptures and inscriptions are proof of its existence.
In ancient India there was practice of having Nagarvadhus (brides of town). Devadasi system, although banned now exemplifies the relationship between prostitution and religion. Devadasis who performed in temples are called “temple prostitutes”. In 16th to 17th century in Goa, women and girls were captured and bought all the way from japan and were made sex slaves by Portuguese traders. Then in late 18thand early 19th century British soldiers visited Nautch dancers frequently.
 As per Human Watch Report India has  20 million women working in the bracket of prostitution. 35.47% of them are under aged i.e. below 18 years (child abuse). Delhi and Mumbai are the hottest centres for this flesh trade.,Mumbai itself has 2, 00,000 sex workers amongst which 50% are HIV positive.. The most infamous red light areas in India are GB road in New Delhi, Budhwar Peth in Pune, Kamaithipura in Mumbai etc.

We  have laws which forbid organized prostitution but we have the largest sex industry in Asia.  Don’t you think our actions and statements are contradictory?

Legal status in India
In India according to the laws, practising prostitution is not a crime  if it is done voluntarily and individually otherwise i.e. its organization is definitely a crime. In other words India has legalized prostitution but it attempts to hide it from public.

The law which governs prostitution in India is PITA(immoral traffic prevention act) (1986), amendment to the primary law SITA( (1956).Major features of the law are:

• Neither a prostitute can solicit/seduce in public place nor can a client ask for sexual favours in public domain (i.e. within 200yards of public place).

• Organized prostitution (brothels and pimping) is illegal.

• Sex worker cannot be below 18 years of age.

Human trafficking is against law.

• Publication of phone number of call girls is banned.

In essence “A prostitute who is above 18 years works for herself and uses her own premises for entertaining clients keeping in mind that it is publically decent, she is conducting herself lawfully.”

The path that Indian constitution has chosen is middle one and bogus. It has huge flaws which give a platform for exploitation, corruption, child abuse, clandestine prostitution, HIV-AIDS to spawn.

Positives


Prostitution is a grim reality, which we cannot be ignored. If we don’t see it, it does not imply that it doesn’t exist. It’s very much there in our society, shielded by hypocrisy of our “MORAL SENSITIVE SOCIETY”. It is practically next to impossible to eradicate prostitution due to its clandestine nature. What can be done is to legalize it, regulate it. Legalization will do following favours:

• Under the present status of laws, sex workers are not protected under normal worker laws. But if legalized sex workers will be protected under normal labour laws and will be entitled to minimum wage benefits, compensation for injuries or other benefits that are common in other kinds of work.

• Legalize it and tax it. It will help in knowing the financial statistics of this trade. It will put a check on black money and will add up to GDP.

• Legalization will help in putting an end on exploitation of prostitutes on the hands of police thus reducing their dependency on police for letting them work in solace. Laws on prostitution in India are bogus which gives an option of their easy distortion (like charging prostitutes for public indecency) in case sex workers refuse to pay them commission.

Legalization of prostitution will help in venting out sexual energy of men who otherwise are reasons for rapes, molestation and murders. It will help in reducing crime rates.

• Legalization of prostitution will help in regulating sex industry by licensing prostitutes. It will help in keeping track on various statistics of this trade like age of prostitutes, minimum wage, health etc.

• Legalization will help in keeping an eye on STDs like HIV-AIDS, syphilis, gonorrhoea. HIV-AIDS is a cause of concern because acc. To statistics 50% of prostitutes in Mumbai are HIV positive. If legalized licensed prostitutes will regularly go through medical checkups and the license would be cancelled for those who suffer from this disease, thus preventing further spread of disease.

• Legalization would help in prohibiting Human trafficking .It will help in curbing teenage prostitution. Brothels indulging in child/teen prostitution could be penalized.

• Pimps/dalaals who procure women and child like cattle could be prosecuted for exploitation.

• Money, time and energy are spent on enforcement of various laws restricting prostitution. Customers, sex workers and pimps are caught again and again, once caught they have to undergo whole legal procedure. 

The Flip Side


Legalization of an evil doesn’t validate it. Prostitution is a form of sexual exploitation and legalization of any evil can be catastrophic. There are various reasons as to why we shouldn’t think of legalization of prostitution which are listed below:

• Legalization means that we are objectifying human beings, who can be purchased or sold. Is it correct?

• Legalization of prostitution doesn’t eradicate it, it expands it.

• Legalization of prostitution would mean acceptance of defeat which sends wrong message to society. It would present as a well recognized career option. And now pause and think how many of us would appreciate our children taking it.

• Commercial sexual exploitation is a form of slavery, and slavery cannot be legalized.

• Legalization can possibly endanger family structure because of free availability of sex outside home. It also wrecks the personality of an individual. In Indian society marriage is a holy institution, and any such deed like engagement with a prostitute is considered as an act of infidelity which further poses threat to institution of marriage.

• Many young women although financially stable take it up to earn those extra bucks to support their luxurious life. Legalization will encourage their decision, further encouraging it as a career choice.

• If legalized and left  unregulated, it can be catastrophic. Pimps can then play hide and seek with law causing much more harm to sex workers and their rights. Spread of diseases like AIDS would increase.

Neither legalization nor criminalization can be a perfect solution. However acceptance of prostitutes by the society will be a step forward in curbing this evil. If prostitution is legalized, half of the sex workers will suffer cancellation of their licenses because of the fact that they carry HIV- AIDS infection. Now think about their future. Where will they go? Where will they earn their living from? Will any company or organization recruit them? Forget about companies, will we  accept them? And if prostitution is criminalized,  it will be difficult for them to earn a livelihood.It is a no-win fight.

How hypocrites are we? We look at prostitutes with contempt, even though we know that they are victims of circumstances. Ever imagined why they decided to take up this trade? Ever sympathized with them?  Ever been to the place where they live ? Those narrow streets, next to the  dilapidated buildings where sunlight fears to enter, speak tons about their grief. Every window tells a heart rending tale of the desire to be free. It is time we empathize with their pain and give them the right to walk in daylight without the need to hide their individuality in those wee hours of dark.




Enhanced by Zemanta

38 comments:

  1. It doesn't help that we use "whore' and 'prostitute' to demean a woman. The same society that loves taking a high moral ground whilst judging a woman's character, doesn't think twice before exploiting her for sex. It's only in our country where hypocrisy is more acceptable, sex-trade and sex-workers have to bear with the stigma.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. You are right Purba. I wanted to share this honest piece because it exposes the hypocrisy in our society. And closing eyes as if it did not exist, doesn't help at all.

      Delete
  2. Very thoughtful article.
    The hypocrisy in India is appalling and it would take more than law and time to give a proper status to prostitutes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks for stoping by and reading it..! well nothing but acceptance will do magic and healing..

      Delete
    2. Thanks for reading Rajlakshmi.

      Delete
  3. We truly are hypocrites! Stigma on prostitution is just another face of it

    ReplyDelete
  4. yes it is.. the change has to start from individual level! if i at my level refuse to stigmatize it , it will do great deal ..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well said Anshu. This piece is a small step but a positive one.

      Delete
  5. It is a vicious circle, to me. We cannot eradicate it, and we cannot purge it either. The only thing we can do is acknowledge it. Besides, I don't think that the laws are bogus; for example, Neither a prostitute can solicit/seduce in public place nor can a client ask for sexual favours in public domain (i.e. within 200yards of public place).

    • Organized prostitution (brothels and pimping) is illegal.

    The law says that organized prostitution, dalaals and pimps are illegal. If someone decides to take it up as a profession ('escort service' being the common euphemism), it is not illegal because it is a profession which some people as you rightly pointed out indulge in to earn extra bucks for extravagant spending. Honourable or not, is something that social customs have decided, but should be a personal choice, since our constitution also talks of safeguarding the fundamental rights, freedom of expression, and profession (Article 19, I think).
    But one point is certain, we just cannot ignore it.

    Nice contemplation!

    Blasphemous Aesthete

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You have said it Anshul. It is a vicious circle. I wanted to share this article as it exposes our hypocritical society.

      Delete
  6. The article exposes the hypocrisy of our society. Nicely written Anshu. Thanks Alka for hosting this wonderful writer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pleasure. This was too powerful to be ignored.

      Delete
  7. Anshu you have thrashed the topic thoroughly and it leaves me thinking what could be the ideal solution.....frankly the answer eludes me....of course the stigma and the exploitation are the worst features-applicable only to the woman...it takes two to tango but only the woman is ostracized....even nature has been partial-she is left holding the baby.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  8. I think the first option is the only possibility.
    The second one "Be diligent and completely uproot it" is something that the Taliban is trying now (and the so called leaders practice it discretely behind closed doors)
    But in our country (of Kamasutra) it is going to take a very very long time to come out with some sensible solution.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  9. Thought provoking write up Anshu . Its a perfect example of Classic Indian Hypocrisy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We will rank no. 1 if measured on scale of hypocrisy! well thank you so much for reading..:)

      Delete
  10. No one goes into prostitution willingly, yet these women are made out to be criminals, while the people who sell them, the pimps and their customers get away with neither legal action nor a fall in social standing. What a hypocritical society we are! Very well written, Anshu.
    Alka - I've added the link.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Can't thank you enough Corinne. That's very thoughtful of you.

      Delete
    2. exactly! and thank you so much for reading..:)

      Delete
  11. What a thoughtful post!! We define hypocrisy. We cannot give them the means that would stop them from venturing into this field, but we also cannot let them remain in this field to make their ends meet.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I make sure that I avoid the word, 'prostitution' since I find it demeaning to the women who are compelled and it's not a matter of choice. It is high time to regulate the sector and avoid the hypocrite argument called, 'morality.' Very honest and detailed post, Anshu and thanks Alka for putting it:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thank you so much for stopping by and reading ...:)

      Delete
  13. I wish we live in a society where we do not treat humans as objects but I think that will never be possible. We are not wired that way. People will always be sold and bought and used.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. reality is always appalling...
      thank you for reading..:)

      Delete
  14. Makes me sad but it is the bitter truth. Women who are victims are also the ones who are the harassed while their customers and pimps have no such issues. Written from the heart, Anshu!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. all i want to say is in India we are making biology as destiny..thank you for reading..:)

      Delete
  15. Red Handed, Vishal, Rachna, Amit....thank you for reading.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I kind of found this article very confusing. What is the solution then? If there is no solution, we leave it as it is, right? and Just sympathize with them? How is it going to improve the situation?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Diwakar, I hope Anshu, my guest writer expresses her point of view.

      It is confusing as there are no easy answers.

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  17. Very thought provoking article Anshu !
    I also cant take any stand other than empathising ........
    Thanks for writing this

    ReplyDelete